Print

Consumers Fare Worse Under Payday Loan Bans

Federal Bank of New York Staff Report

Preliminary findings from a new staff report, “Payday Holiday: How Households Fare after Payday Credit Bans,” by Federal Reserve Bank of New York Research Officer Donald P. Morgan and Cornell University graduate student Michael R. Strain, conclude that payday loan bans result in increased credit problems for consumers.

The report compares households in states with payday loans with households in both Georgia and North Carolina, states which eliminated payday loans in May 2004 and December 2005 respectively. Households in Georgia and North Carolina bounced more checks, complained more to the Federal Trade Commission about lenders and debt collectors, and filed for Chapter 7 (“no asset”) bankruptcy at a higher rate. These findings indicate that households without access to payday loans are forced to use costlier credit and suffer greater financial difficulties.

Full results of the study (PDF)
Review all study highlights (PDF)

Noted in the report:

Consumers suffer greater credit problems under payday loan bans

  • “Georgians and North Carolinians do not seem better off since their states outlawed payday credit: they have bounced more checks, complained more about lenders and debt collectors, and have filed for Chapter 7 (“no asset”) bankruptcy at a higher rate.”

  • “On average, the Federal Reserve check processing center in Atlanta returned 1.2 million more checks per year after the ban. At $30 per item, depositors paid an extra $36 million per year in bounced check fees after the ban.”

  • “Total complaints against lenders and debt collectors [in North Carolina] rose by over a third relative to other states…”

  • “[Overall,] Chapter 7 filing rates increased… 8.5 percent [under the ban].”


Payday loan bans force consumers into worse options

  • “The contraction in payday credit supply caused former borrowers to bounce more checks, thus aggravating their already marginal circumstances. To stave off bankruptcy, distressed borrowers pawned or sold assets. For those who ultimately succumbed to their financial problems, the loss of assets made chapter 7 [bankruptcy] the natural choice.”

  • “[The] slipping down, with less rescheduling of debts, but more “deadbeats” and “no asset” bankruptcies, seems to fit the picture [of] a marginal payday customer pushed over the edge.”

  • “Banning payday loans did not save Georgian households $154 million per year, as CRL projected, it cost them millions per year in returned check fees.”

  • “…we take our results as evidence of a slipping down in the lives of would-be payday borrowers.”


Payday loans alleviate financial distress

  • “Most of our findings contradict the debt trap hypothesis.”

  • “Our findings show that [payday loans] help to avoid more quotidian disasters, like bouncing a mess of checks, or getting hassled at work by debt collectors.”

Connecting With Our Communities

Managing household finances can be a daunting task. However, by using solid budgeting and savings techniques, you can accomplish major financial goals. In the Customer Resource Center, CFSA offers a variety of payday advance resources that support and encourage responsible lending practices, and highlight the vital role of our members’ stores in neighborhoods near you.


Login
Forgot Username or Password?

TO OUR MEMBERS

Thanks for visiting the CFSA Web site. CFSA values you as a member. Consequently, we are constantly seeking new ways to enhance your membership experience. As such, the information in this section is restricted to members only. If you are a CFSA member, please enter your username and password. If you have forgotten your login info, send an e-mail to Member@CFSAA.com.

Login
Forgot Username or Password?

TO OUR PARTNERS

Here you will find an aggregate of industry research, comprehensive data, and benchmarking tools from the short-term lending industry. They cover all payday advance business areas – consumer demographics, media hits, the latest policy initiatives, among others. Click here to access to the partner's resource library.

Login
Forgot Username or Password?

For Our Policymakers

CFSA works at the federal, state, and local levels educate legislators and regulators about the role of payday advances in the broader financial services arena. This section provides resources for policymakers who believe in access to credit, want to preserve financial options and ensure balanced, substantive consumer protections. Click here to enter the Policymaker Resource Library.